Popper, Strauss and the Alleged Totalitarism of Plato
Keywords:
L. Strauss. K. Popper. Ironic-Plato. Totalitarian-Plato.Abstract
This paper addresses the alleged totalitarianism in Plato’s Republic, more specifically Karl Poppers accusation in Open Society and his Enemies that Plato’s political program – opposed to social change, individual liberty, isonomic justice, and enlightenment - is frankly totalitarian. We discuss this thesis of Popper in the light of the interpretation by Leo Strauss of the Republicwhere he rejects any totalitarianism in the political project of the Platonic Republic. Developing a hermeneutic that could be called “ironic-dissimulatory” and “dramatic-comic”, Strauss argues that the realization of the perfect state idealized in the Republic is at the same time unwanted and impossible, since its existence requires the abstraction of eros and the coincidence between political power and philosophy. Our argument is that Strauss’s analysis of the concepts of justice and the parallelism between individual and society in the Republic proved more accurate than Popper’s.
Downloads
References
ARISTÓFANES. A Revolução das Mulheres. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar, 1996.
ARISTÓTELES. Ética a Nicômaco. São Paulo: Nova Cultural, 1987.
KLEIN, J. A Commentary on Plato's Menon. The University of North
PLATÃO. A República. Tradução Maria Helena da Rocha Pereira. 13 ed. Lisboa: Fundação Calouste Gulbenkian, 2012.
______. Mênon. Tradução Maura Iglesias. 3 ed. São Paulo: Loyola, 2005.
POPPER, K. A Miséria do Historicismo. Tradução Octany S. da Mota e Leonidas Hegenberg. São Paulo, EDUSP, 1980.
POPPER, K. A sociedade aberta e seus inimigos: o fascínio de Platão. Tradução Milton Amado. 3 ed. São Paulo: Itatiaia, Editora da Universidade de São Paulo, 1987.
STRAUSS, L. La ciudad y el hombre. Buenos Aires: Katz, 2005.
______. The Problem of Socrates: Five Lectures. In: STRAUSS, L. The Rebirth of Classical Political Rationalism. The University of Chicago Press, 1989
______. Seminar on Plato’s Menon. Chicago: University of Chicago, 1966.
THOMPSON, J. A. K. Irony: An Historical Introduction. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1926.
VEGETTI, M. Defender Platão de Popper (ou de si mesmo?). In: VEGETTI, M. Um paradigma no céu: Platão político, de Aristóteles ao século XX. Tradução Maria da Graça Gomes de Pina. São Paulo: Annablume, 2010. Cap. 7, p. 193-227.
.png){kind=logo}
